2,000 People Nationwide Surveyed: ANSWERS PAINT RICH, DISTURBING PORTRAIT OF AMERICANS' VIEWS ON AMERICA For many Americans, "politics" can be boiled down to "Who ya' gonna vote for?" But it is the attitudes that lie behind the question that offer insights into the nation's political culture. The Post-Modernity Project at the University of Virginia, led by director and "Culture Wars" author James Davison Hunter, has combined forces with Carl Bowman, a sociology professor at Bridgewater College, and the Gallup Organization to conduct one of the most comprehensive surveys on American political culture undertaken. In 2,000 face-to-face interviews nationwide, each lasting over an hour, Americans of diverse social, cultural and economic backgrounds were asked questions about their ideals, beliefs and values. "The Survey of American Political Culture," provides a rich portrait of American public opinion. Leading the analysis of the survey data is Hunter, the W. R. Kenan Professor of Sociology at U.Va. Calling the survey "The State of Disunion," Hunter believes it reflects Americans' perceptions of, and expectations for, American democracy. "The survey penetrates America's most recent dilemmas -- the apparent disaffection with our present political system, the prominence of special-interest groups, such as the Christian Right, and the proliferation of anti-government militias. Observers write about the fragmentation of our culture, the erosion of morales, the consequences of new class divisions, and the loss of legitimacy for key public institutions. Although their warnings are ominous and repeated by anecdote, they have rarely been tested against empirical data. This survey ascertains how much of talk about America's problems can be substantiated," Hunter said. Following is a synopsis of the 13-page summary of the Post Modernity Project's survey of American political culture. For a copy of the survey's executive summary or a full report, contact the Post-Modernity Project at (804) 924-7705 or the U.Va. News Office at (804) 924-3890. Hunter, who will be available periodically for interviews, can be reached at (804) 924-7705. If Hunter is unavailable, other researchers in the Post Modernity Project, a coordinated, multi-perspective examination of the nature and consequences of contemporary social change, can answer survey questions. In addition, Bowman is at (540) 828-5349. Major findings of the survey of American political culture include: General Agreement on Ideals The survey shows remarkably high levels of support for the "American creed." For example: ¥ More than 9 out of 10 Americans (94%) agreed that it is important to teach children that "America's contribution is one of expanding freedom for more and more people." ¥ 95% said it is important to teach children that "America is the world's great melting pot, in which people from different countries are united into one nation." ¥ 96% said it is important to teach children that "with hard work and perseverance, anyone can succeed in America." The strong endorsement of American ideals is seen in people's opinions about the political system. For example: ¥ A majority (56%) indicated that it has "respect for the political institutions in America," and 76% expressed pride in "living under our system of government." ¥ 69% felt that "our system of government is the best possible system." Pessimism About America However, despite the endorsements of ideals, Americans expressed pervasive pessimism about how the political system is working and America as a whole. ¥ Only 10% felt that the U.S. is improving overall, and only 1 out of 100 said that the improvement is strong. ¥ 50% said that the U.S. is in decline. One out of five contended that it is a strong decline. Among answers that showed disaffection toward the government were: ¥ 21% expressed no confidence when asked to react to "when the government decides to solve a problem, the problem will actually be solved." ¥ 63% believed that the "federal government controls too much of our daily lives." Half of those surveyed felt that ordinary people "don't have any say about what the government does." ¥ The majority (61%) agreed with the concept that the best government is one that governs least. The majority favored reducing the size of the federal government and shifting many functions from the federal to state level. Many expressed pervasive dissatisfaction in how government functions, particularly at the national level. ¥ The majority are "worried" or "upset." However, those at the socio-economic bottom are the least upset with government. The white, well-educated, middle classes, mostly from small towns in the eastern-central states are the most worried, and those who expressed the most negative sentiments generally. Americans expressed cynicism toward political leadership; ¥ Two-thirds of the American public believe that while the American system of government is good, "the people running it are incompetent; 90% believe that "people in government waste a lot of the money we pay in taxes." ¥ 7 out of 10 people believe that "most elected officials don't care what people like me think." ¥ 8 out of 10 agreed that "most politicians are more interested in winning elections than in doing what is right." Trends in Thoughts about Political Leadership In 1966, 41% had a "great deal of confidence" in the presidency. One decade later, the figure was 23%, a number that held fairly steady for two decades, according to Harris and National Opinion Research Center polls. In this survey only 13% has a "great deal of confidence" in the executive branch. In 1966, 42% of the population had a great deal of confidence in Congress. By the mid '70s, the number had dropped to the teens, and in this survey, it is 5%. "The public's increasingly negative opinion of politicians is coupled with distrust for the larger body of cultural and political elites -- those people who run major institutions such as the government, universities and the mass media," Hunter points out. ¥ The majority regard the governing elite as insensitive to people's concerns, unconcerned with values and morality, unconcerned with the common good and only concerned about the elites' own agenda. ¥ The majority also views the governing elite as irreligious, out of touch with reality, not in the mainstream. "Whether confused, angry, resentful or indifferent, the vast majority of Americans (81%) resonates with the stinging indictment that "political events these days seem more like theater or entertainment than like something to be taken seriously,'" Hunter observes. The Pressure Points in American Democracy Racial Matters The survey indicates a surprising similarity about how much blacks and whites agree with each other on matters of political culture. ¥ Blacks and whites embrace middle-class morality at roughly the same levels and blacks manifest as much, if not more, religious commitment than whites. ¥ Blacks are as committed to the American dream as are whites; they are as civic minded and as supportive of the political system. The survey, however, indicates that the most important differences between blacks and whites are their opposing views toward race relations and policy. ¥ When asked, for example, to consider if the quality of life for African-Americans has improved, deteriorated or stayed the same over the past 10 years, nearly two thirds (62%) of all whites thought it had gotten better -- a figure twice as high as that expressed by African-Americans. ¥ Only 12% of whites thought that the quality of life for African-Americans had gotten worse; nearly three times the number of African-Americans felt it had. Social Elites The "social elites," who the survey authors described as individuals who have at least some graduate-level education and whose occupation is either small business owner, manager or public official, professional or retiree with income of at least $50,000 a year, were characterized in the following ways by respondents: ¥ Social elites are the least likely to believe literally in the Bible or to pray frequently. They tend to describe their beliefs as theologically liberal. They are the least likely to say they believe in God and the most likely to say they believe in a "universal spirit or life force." ¥ The social elites are least likely to reject as immoral such behaviors as pornography, marijuana use, cigarettes, alcohol, sex before marriage and homosexual relations and homosexual marriages. The Christian Right The survey's answers present a portrayal of the Christian Right. ¥ The Christian Right is composed disproportionately of women (58% as compared to 42% men). Members are also disproportionately from the South; nearly half is from that region. ¥ Over 96% is white. ¥ The Christian Right members are among the most unwavering in their commitment to the political system. Yet, they display a remarkable pessimism about American society. 81% said they thought America was in either strong or moderate decline, compared to 51% of the total population. The survey showed that: ¥ Contrary to the general media impression of the Christian Right, the majority of Americans view those in the movement as patriotic and well-meaning -- people of character and conviction who are concerned about the family and morality. The Gay Community The survey confirms the public's increasing acceptance of homosexuality, as shown in other recent polls. ¥ Only one-third of those surveyed thought that homosexuality is "morally wrong and should not be legally tolerated." However, about two-thirds disagreed with an assertion that homosexuals should have the right to marry and adopt children. The Politics of Paranoia The survey also explored characteristics of those who distrust and dislike the American system of government and who believe the government conspires against the interests of citizens. ¥ The survey found that strong suspicions of conspiracy flourish in the West, fade toward the East and perish across the Alleghanies. The more physically distant a region is from the seat of national power, the more distrustful are its inhabitants. ¥ Those who lament a decline in quality of national leaders are likely to call for congressional term limits. ¥ Those who harbor fears of governmental conspiracy are likely to oppose restrictions on the sale and use of handguns. They also favor reducing the federal government. Middle Class Fears The survey shows that the middle classes are not especially worried about the economy, their jobs or personal finances. Instead they fear they are losing what makes their everyday living important -- their Judeo Christian God, family life, moral commitments, work ethic and public school system. "It is not a 'fear of falling' that haunts the middle classes, but a fear of the curtain falling upon their way of life," Hunter notes. The disaffection with political institutions and those who run them seems to be structural -- largely a function of the size of the institutions, the frailties of their leaders, the abstraction of how the political system operates, and the distance Americans feel toward them, Hunter concludes in the survey's summary. The disaffection of the middle classes is particularly troubling, he observes. "When the middle classes retreat into disaffection, the vitality of civic institutions can only be weakened. The middle classes' fear of insignificance -- that their way of life is being eroded and becoming less viable -- raises questions about their long-term commitment to the American political process. The critical question is: 'Is this situation sustainable over time?'" Hunter asks. ### October 22, 1996